Home / ADR concerning arzt.eu and boot.eu
ADR concerning arzt.eu and boot.eu
Historical decision archive on domain law. For the transfer to today's conflict, protective rights, domain extension and the rules at the time of the new procedure are decisive.
Unofficial translation of a historical decision. For quotations and the precise wording of the order, consult the original-language text.
Historical decision
Complainant
Name: Cervos Enterprises Ltd, Andreas Constantinou
Address: Pavlou Angelinide 9
Limassol Agia Fyla
Cyprus
3110
Email: office@cervos.info
Telephone No: 0049.30.8844810
Fax No: 0049.30.8813689
Authorised representative of the complainant
Complainant
Name: Internet portal and marketing GmbH, Markus Koettl
Address: Rosa-Hofmann-Strasse 18a
Salzburg
Austria
5020
Email: domain@ipmarketing.info
Telephone No: +43.6644136483
Fax No: not known
Respondent's authorised representative
Controversial domain name: Doctor, BOOT, DIAET, FERIEN, GARDEN
Other procedures
Concerning the domain names arzt.eu, ferien.eu and garten.eu:
1. ADR method No 1717 (already decided).
2. Regional Court of Salzburg Az. 14 Cg 194/06a Internet portal and Marketing GmbH ./. Axel Arnulf Pfennig (trial against ADR decision No. 1) 1717) (pending)
English version of the Decision: An English version of this Decision is attached as Appendix 1
Situation
The parties argue about the domain names of ORDER, BOOT, DIAET, FERIEN, GARDEN. The complainant is the owner of 5 identical word marks registered with the Maltese Trademark Office. The registration is effective since 3.8.2005 for the brand Ferien, and since 30.8.2005 for the remaining brands. The respondent requested the first domain name on 13.4.2006, and the remaining domain names on 7.12.2005. Their registrations are based on five trademark applications with the Swedish Trademark Office, which have been effective since 25.11.2005. These are the following registrations: "&A&R&Z&T&", "&B&O&OT&", "&D&I&A&E&T&", "&F&E&R&I&E&N&" and "&G&A&R&T&E&N&". The appellant desires the revocation of the disputed domain names and
the transfer of the domain names in dispute to them. The Respondent requests:
I. to reject the complaint against the domain registrations boot.eu and diaet.eu, II. the out-of-court dispute settlement procedure with regard to the domain names arzt.eu, urlaub.eu and garten.eu until the final conclusion of the proceedings pending at the Regional Court Salzburg Internet Portal and Marketing GmbH. Axel Arnulf Pfennig, Az. 14 Cg 194/06a, and
III. to reject the complaint against the domain registrations arzt.eu, urlaub.eu and garten.eu after the final conclusion of the court proceedings pending before the Regional Court of Salzburg. In the alternative, I. the out-of-court dispute settlement procedure until the final conclusion of the proceedings pending at the Regional Court of Salzburg Internetportal and Marketing GmbH. Axel Arnulf Pfennig, Az. 14 Cg 194/06a, and II. to reject the appeal after the final conclusion of the court proceedings pending before the Regional Court of Salzburg. In the alternative, it shall be requested:
reject the complaint.
The complaint was lodged on 1 December 2006. The verification of the payment and the confirmation of receipt of the complaint took place on 4.12.2006. The formal date of the procedure shall be 12.12.2006. On 26 January 2007, the Respondent submitted its reply, with the confirmation of receipt from the Czech Arbitral Tribunal not taking place until 29 January 2007. The arbitral tribunal selected the undersigned as arbitrator for the case on 30 January 2007. On the same day, the declaration of consent and the declaration of impartiality and independence, as well as the notification of the appointment of the ADR arbitration committee and the expected date of the decision were made. Within the specified time limit, the Respondent requested that the member of the arbitration committee be challenged. Following the reply of the undersigned to the appeal, the Czech Arbitral Tribunal decided on 9.2.2007 to reject the request. According to Art. B 5 (e) ADR Rules: the Provider’s decision is final and non-impeachable, the arbitral tribunal has instructed the Signatory to proceed with the proceedings.
Presentation by the parties
Complainant
According to the Appellant, the registration of the domain names "boot.eu", "diaet.eu", "garten.eu", "ferien.eu" and "arzt.eu" on the part of the Respondent is considered speculative and abusive within the meaning of the art. 21 of Regulation (EC) No. 874/2004. It considers that the conditions of both art. 21, par. 1 lit. a as well as of the art. 21, par. 1 lit. b.
The complainant has based it on its above (see below). the trademarks listed above also apply for registration of EU domain names in the context of the Sunrise period and intend to use these domains to promote the services protected by their trademarks.
On the other hand, the Respondent could not assert any rights or legitimate interests in the domain name at issue. The brands "&A&R&Z&T&", "&B&O&OT&", "&D&I&A&E&T&", "&F&E&R&I&E&N&" and "&G&A&R&T&E&N&" each consist of an unpronounceable drawing structure that, even in its written form, looks highly confusing and does not produce a coherent readable word. The use of this design for the marking of goods or services or a business operation does not take place at present and, in view of the unspeakable design of this construction, would also appear to be excluded in the future. It is clear, not only in view of the unusable nature of these signs as trade marks, but also of the various (imaginative) product lists on which these trade mark applications are based, that the Respondent does not intend and will not be able to use these trade marks in commercial transactions.
In addition, the procedural domain names are also registered in bad faith. The - generic - terms "doctor", "boat", "diet", "holiday" and "garden" can only be inferred from the trademark applications of the respondent if one omits the numerous special characters, which are located at the beginning and end of the word as well as between all letters. The Respondent had obviously chosen such constructs as pseudo marks in order to achieve with their help within the framework of the staggered domain registration (Sunrise period) that the special characters acc. Art. 11 par. 2 of Regulation (EC) No. 874/2004 at the choice of the applicant and they receive the corresponding generic terms as domain names.
The underlying trademark applications were filed on 10 October. August 2005, granted on 25 August 2005. November 2005, in direct connection with the Sunrise procedure for the registration of EU domain names. It should be noted that the Respondent not only applied for the above-mentioned trademarks, but also a larger number of other trademarks with generic conceptual content in German, which are joined together in the same way using the special character "&". As proof, the Appellant has submitted an extract from the Swedish Trade Mark Register as Appendix 7, indicating that the Respondent was informed on 10 and 11 March 2016 that: August 2005 33 of these drawings.
In addition, the respondent had applied for a large number of other generic terms of the German language as trademarks in Belgium and Austria in order to also exploit these trademarks in the context of the Sunrise procedure for the registration of EU domain names. Respondent and its sole shareholder and managing director, Mr Koettl, are already the subject of intensive reporting on the Internet due to the obvious abuse of the Sunrise proceedings.
Consequently, the respondent had deliberately resorted to the transcription rule of the art by abusive means. 11 par. 2 of Regulation (EC) No. 874/2004 devised trade marks which, due to the use of special signs, were so unusual that they did not have to fear lengthy opposition proceedings. The insertion of special characters means that the generic terms can no longer be identified at first glance, since the traffic does not perceive the resulting character formations as readable or pronounceable words. The marks are obviously only designed for the purpose of the rule of the art. 11 par. 2 of Regulation (EC) No. 874/2004. However, this contradicts the meaning and purpose of this scheme, which is exclusively intended not to deny in principle the possibility of EU domain registration to holders of earlier special name rights.
Finally, the complainant provides a detailed list of jurisdictions of the Czech Arbitral Tribunal on the interpretation of Art. 11 VO 874/2004 to reaffirm its position.
Complainant
Request for suspension of proceedings
According to the Respondent, the domain names at issue arzt.eu, urlaub.eu and garten.eu are already covered by CAC procedure No. 01717 (Axel Arnulf Pfennig ./). Internet portal and marketing GmbH) were the subject of the dispute. In this case, the arbitral tribunal has ordered the annulment of all domain names in dispute, including the domain names arzt.eu, ferien.eu and garten.eu. An action against the implementation of this decision was filed in due time with the locally competent Regional Court of Salzburg. This action is advisable to the EURid and the decision of the arbitration committee has therefore not yet been implemented. The appellant therefore requests the suspension of the proceedings, since the domain names arzt.eu, urlaub.eu and garten.eu at issue are the subject of ordinary court proceedings before the Regional Court of Salzburg.
About the complainant
The Respondent provides the following background information about the Complainant: The Complainant is a Cypriot company which, according to its company report, has as its object the “registration, storage, purchase, sale and trade in trademarks and registration, storage, purchase, sale and trade with domain names” (so in the CAC case No. 01584 – ksb.eu. The complainant is the owner of approx. 150 Maltese registered marks (a list of such marks has been attached as Appendix 1 to the reply). According to information provided by the Respondent, the Complainant has ca. 140 applications for preferential registration of domain names have been submitted, including "weissrussland.eu", "weisswein.eu", "werkstoffe.eu", "thermometer.eu", "suedamerika.eu", "sterne.eu", "sekt.eu", "rotwein.eu", "producer.eu", "porzellan.eu", "pkv.eu", "physik.eu", "oel.eu", "mmz.eu", "luzern.eu", "kopfschmerzen.eu", "kondom.eu", "kfz.eu", "jobboerse.eu", "investoren.eu", "heiraten.eu", "haarpflege.eu", "hautplflege.eu", "handylogos.eu", "geographie.eu", "fut.eu", "fruechte.eu", "faq.eu", "erkaeltung.eu" and "enzyme.eu".
The complainant’s conduct has already been the subject of numerous ADR proceedings before the Czech Court of Arbitration. In these proceedings, the arbitral tribunals came to the conclusion that the respective domain names in dispute had been badly registered and ordered the transfer of the domain names. These cases are:
1. CAC Case No 03557 - Schaeffler KG ./. Cervos Enterprises Ltd
2. CAC Case No 01584 - Kocian Solc Balastik, advokatni kancelar, Ladislav Smejkal Cervos Enterprises Ltd
3. CAC Case No 01827 – Müller Ltd. & Co. KG . Cervos Enterprises Ltd
4. CAC Case No 02035 - Warema Renkhoff GmbH. Cervos Enterprises Ltd
5. CAC Case No 03202 - Studienkreis GmbH ./. Cervos Enterprises Ltd
About the rights of the domain owner according to art. 21 (1) a) Regulation 874/2004
The granting of a claim for the transfer of a domain name constitutes in accordance with art. 21 (1) (a) of Regulation (EC) No. 874/2004 stipulates that the domain owner cannot invoke any rights or legitimate interests in the domain name. The burden of proof that the domain owner has no right or legitimate interest in a domain name, as is apparent from art. B12(g)(2) of the ADR Rules unquestionably results in the appellant. Such evidence was not provided by the Appellant, as it merely refers to the Respondent’s trademark registrations and claims that the Respondent’s trademarks were not used and concluded without further substantiation that the Respondent therefore had no right or legitimate interest in the domain name at issue. Contrary to the opinion of the Appellant, the Respondent can very well invoke a right or legitimate interest in the domain name at issue: The Respondent is entitled to a legitimate interest in the domain name at issue, since these are formed from the smooth descriptive components “Doctor”, “Boot”, “Diaet”, “Ferien” and “Garden” and the Respondent plans to use the domain names at issue in a descriptive manner.
The registration of a descriptive term as a domain name in order to be able to use it in a descriptive manner in the following constitutes a legitimate interest within the meaning of the art. 21 (1) a) of Regulation (EC) No. 874/2004. Experience has shown that domain names formed from generic terms are of great interest. An unmanageable number of such terms are registered as domain names. Almost every generic term can be found on the Internet under the corresponding domain name information, which is usually related to this term. Some domain names, which are formed from a generic term, also include portals that commercial providers can also use for a fee. From this exercise, which has been observed for years and is not legally objectionable, the need has also developed to register as many such descriptive terms as domain names as possible.
The fact that the domain names in dispute are formed from descriptive terms rather precludes the rights of third parties being infringed by their registration and creates a legitimate interest in the domain name within the meaning of the art. 21 (1) a) of Regulation 874/2004.
About bad faith registration or use by art. 21 (1)a) Regulation 874/2004
The burden of proof that the domain owner has registered or uses the domain name in bad faith lies with the complainant (cf. paragraphs 2 and 3). Art. B12(g)(3) and (4) of the ADR Regulations. Nor was such evidence provided by the complainant. It merely claims that the Respondent registered numerous trademarks in 2005 and alleged abuse of the Sunrise process related to those registrations. Evidence that the Respondent has provided the domain names in the sense of the art. 21, par. 1 (b) in V.M. Article 21, par. 3 of Regulation 874/2004 has registered or used bad faith, is completely absent. Just the reference to the fact that the Respondent has registered numerous descriptive domain names in the Sunrise period I on the basis of corresponding trademarks does not initially constitute proof of a malicious registration according to m. Art. 21 (1) b) of Regulation (EC) No. 874/2004. Rather, the registration of descriptive domain names is a practice that has been common for years and is not legally objectionable.
The only question discussed by the appellant in connection with the allegation of bad faith, whether the conditions for a phased registration of the domain names in dispute under the Sunrise rules existed, is not the subject of this procedure, but must be clarified exclusively in proceedings against the register (EURid) (see only CAC Case No. 1). 00283 - LTUR Tourismus AG ./. Rücker – lastminute.eu; CAC Case No. 01584 - Kocian Solc Balastik, advokatni kancelar, Ladislav Smejkal Andreas Constantinou – ksb.eu.
The decisions cited by the appellant in this context
CAC Case No. 00398 – barcelona.eu,
CAC Case No. 00265 – live.eu,
CAC Case No. 00394 – frankfurt.eu,
CAC Case No. 00735 – nice.eu,
CAC Case No. 01255 – liechtenstein.eu
CAC Case No. 01049 – five.eu,
CAC Case No. 02221 – reykjavik and
CAC Case No. 01523 – koeln.eu
are all in proceedings according to art. 22, par. 1 (b) of Regulation 874/2004 against the EURid and have been referred to violations of the Sunrise rules and art. 11 of Regulation 874/2004. In none of these cases was there proceedings for speculative or abusive registration under Art. 22, par. 1 (a) of Regulation 874/2004. However, the scope of the present procedure is limited to art. 21 of Regulation 874/2004. Consequently, the decisions cited by the complainant cannot be taken into account.
It should also be noted that the Respondent’s requests for preferential registration of the domain names at issue were rightly granted by the Register, since the requests were based on legally validly registered trademarks and the trademarks in accordance with the rules of the art. 11 of Regulation 874/2004 were correctly transcribed as domain names (cf. only CAC case No. 1). 1867 - The Chancellor Masters & Scholars of the University of Oxford, t/a Oxford University Press, Ms Jo Marks ./. EURid – oxford.eu
Also, evidence that could justify the bad faith of the registration of the domain names in dispute is not apparent. In particular, none of the provisions of Article 21(2) of Regulation (EC) No. 874/2004, by way of example.
a. The Respondent did not register the domain names in dispute for rent or otherwise transfer to owners of names for which there is a right recognised or established under national and/or Community law, but intended to use the domain names descriptively for Internet portals.
Even if one were to assume that the sale of domain names is a motive for domain registration, the bad faith would be of the kind. 21(3)(a) of Regulation (EC) No. 874/2004 is only fulfilled in the specific case if under national or Community law existing rights of the complainant would have led to the registration of the domain names. Since the Respondent had no knowledge of the Complainant at the time of registration of the domain names, this is undoubtedly not the case.
b. Also, there is no registration in disability intention according to art. 21(3)(b) of Regulation (EC) No. 874/2004. The requirement requires that the domain registration has been carried out ‘to prevent a holder of a name which is subject to a law recognised or established under national and/or Community law from using that name as the corresponding domain name’. Nor is there any indication of an intention to obstruct. The Respondent has registered the domain names to use them descriptively. This applies even if a generic term has name or mark rights at the same time.
c. Also other indications of a malicious registration or use of the domain names are not visible. In particular, as already stated, the registration of several descriptive terms as domain names does not constitute malicious behavior, but corresponds to a general and legally unobjectionable practice.
Appraisal and findings
The arbitration committee has taken into account the overall material of the case. The parties have revealed many interesting points about the .eu registration system and the interpretation of Regulation 874/2004. Includes:
1. The question of systematic registration of generic terms.
2. The question of the legality of the sale of domain names, as long as they are descriptive, generic terms for which there is no recognized or defined right of a third party.
3. The question of the suspension of an ADR procedure as long as legal proceedings concerning the disputed domain names are pending before the court of a Member State.
These, as well as all other points of the parties, have been considered by the arbitration commission. However, the Arbitral Commission will refer to all of the above-mentioned issues in Art. B 12 h ADR rules are not received. This provision provides that if, after consideration of all submissions, the arbitration committee finds that the appeal has been made in bad faith, it shall state in its decision that the appeal was made in bad faith and constitutes an abuse of the proceedings. According to transnational civil procedure teaching, this provision belongs to the procedural prerequisites; therefore, it should be put before the examination of material questions.
This is a regulation which in art. 21 VO 874/2004 cannot be found. The latter provision is more concerned with the specification of cases of speculative and abusive registration, but it does not provide an answer to the delicate question of the appellant's need for legal protection. In terms of formal law, every person is entitled to file a complaint as long as he can prove so-called earlier rights to the disputed domain name. In the present case, this procedural stage has already been passed by the complainant: it is undoubtedly actively legitimised, since it filed all domain names in dispute with the Maltese Trade Mark Office at an early stage, i.e. before the respondent’s corresponding trade mark application with the Swedish Trade Mark Office. As a second procedural stage, the legal protection interest in the revocation of the domain names and their transfer to the complainant is now examined.
The cardinal question here is as follows: May the complaint of a party, which formally has earlier rights under art. 10, par. 1 b Regulation 874/2004, if it can be inferred from the circumstances of the specific case that this party has committed an abuse of an institution and is therefore to be classified as a fraudulent party to the process? Under the national law of many EC Member States, this is undoubtedly acceptable. However, the VO 874/2004, as well as the ADR rules, do not provide for anything in this regard. In detail, Art. 22, par. 11 Regulation 874/2004 regulates the following: In proceedings against a domain holder, the arbitration committee decides that the domain name must be revoked if it comes to the conclusion that the registration is speculative or abusive within the meaning of Article 21. The domain name is transferred to the complainant if he requests the registration of this domain name and fulfils the general requirements of Article 4 paragraph 2 b of Regulation 733/2002. Similar things are made of kind. B 11 (b) ADR rules are provided. By type B 11 (d) (1) ADR Rules are intended to prove to the complainant that the domain name (domain name) is identical or confusing with a name for which there are rights recognised or established under the national law of a Member State ... No further requirements are made on the complainant’s person.
The following conclusions could be drawn from the grammatical interpretation of the above provisions:
a. The complainant is primarily to prove that the domain name (domain name) is identical or confusing with a name for which there are rights recognised or established under the national law of a Member State. However, it should not necessarily be his own right, because the wording of the regulation does not provide for a corresponding limitation.
b. The appellant shall comply with the conditions of art. 4, par. 2 b) Regulation 733/2002.
c. The complainant does not need to prove his own legal interest as long as he meets the requirements under (a) and (b).
From this gap arose a contradictory jurisprudence: Thus, on the one hand, in connection with art. 21, par. 1 Regulation 874/2004 in cases 1559, 1652 and 3257 ruled that the appellant bears the burden of proof that he is the holder of prior rights. As long as he is not able to prove any previous right, then his complaint will be rejected. On the other hand, in case 1717 it was decided that for the request for revocation of a domain name it is not necessary for the complainant to be the holder of previous rights. Rather, the latter plays a special role solely on the question of transmission. For this reason, the revocation of the domain names in dispute was ordered in this case, with the request for transfer of the same being rejected.
The Czech Arbitral Court’s case-law tends to suggest that a party without prior rights to a domain name is not allowed the right to lodge complaints. However, it has already been established in the present case that the complainant is the owner of Maltese trademarks, i.e. former rights. A second question therefore arises: Should a claimant’s trade mark application in any circumstances comply with the so-called former rights under Art. 10 Regulation 874/2004 are to be equated?
The legislature had a clear intention, namely to respect previous rights recognised under Community or national law. For this reason, the construction of the staggered registration and the testing site was designed. In plain language it says the following: Meaning those former rights that are indeed worthy of protection. In particular, with regard to trademark rights, the ordinance legislature wanted to protect those trademark registrations which have a certain reference point to a geographically determined business activity of the trademark owner. Trademark applications without any reference to both the country of registration and the business activity of the owner allow prima facie the suspicion that this is a circumvention of the trademark law system (whether domestic or Community) as well as the domain registration in accordance with Regulation 874/2004. This direction is also confirmed in the case law of the Czech Arbitral Tribunal. Thus, in cases 2438 and 3465 it was decided that the disputed trademark applications of the Respondents had taken place solely for the purpose of obtaining an advantage from their proprietors in the so-called “English Trademark Applications”. The Sunrise Period. From a proof of an actual intention to use the mark in some way, every trace was missing.
This situation is rather true in the present case: it has been repeatedly ruled by the Czech Arbitral Tribunal that the complainant "mainly registered the domain ... in order to subsequently transfer it to a third party" (case No. 1). 3557), or that it has "registered the domain name at issue with a view to selling, renting or otherwise transferring it to the holder of a name for which there is a right recognised or established under national and/or Community law" (case No. 1584), or that "the Respondent has never used such marking in any relevant manner, i.e. in particular that he has never used it in connection with the offer of goods or services, that he has not even made demonstrable preparations for such an act before the announcement of the initiation of the ADR, and has not even stated at the time of the effort of the ADR proceedings that he intends to do so". (Case No) 1827.
For these reasons, it was decided in the above cases that the respective domain name had been registered by the then Respondent (and now Complainant) in bad faith. Therefore, in the totality of cases, the revocation of registration and the transfer to the complainant was ordered.
However, the present case is a novelty compared to the above-mentioned cases: The former respondent now goes on the offensive and intends to conquer the domain names in dispute on the basis of her numerous trademark applications. As already noted above, the Czech Arbitral Tribunal has ruled that the trade mark application cannot always be equated to a previous right as long as it took place in order to guarantee an advantage of its holders in the phase of staggered registration. The question now arises as to whether this conclusion should be given general validity, i.e. whether it should be applied in a similar manner to respondents and complainants. The Arbitral Commission, to the best of its knowledge and conscience, sees no reason why it would be inappropriate for this conclusion to be applied universally. The bad faith character of a legal act cannot depend on the party authority. From this it can be deduced that the mass trademark application at the Trademark Office of countries to which the owner has no geographical or business connection can not form an earlier right to domain registration, whether he (the trademark owner) is in the place of the respondent or (as in our case) the complainant.
Now, however, the question arises as to whether the instruments of the ADR rules make sense to reject the present complaint. In the opinion of the arbitration committee, this question can be based on art. B 12 h ADR rules can be approved. The wording of this provision clearly refers to the rejection of the complaint in the event of a bad faith effort or abuse of the proceedings.
So far, the following has been noted:
1. The complainant cannot rely on its Maltese trade mark applications in the sense of previous rights because this model has been repeatedly considered bad faith by the Czech Arbitral Tribunal.
2. The bad faith of this model does not depend on the party office of the owner.
3. According to the prevailing trend of ADR jurisdiction, a complaint is to be rejected as long as the complainant cannot prove any previous rights in the domain name at issue.
The above findings can now be an additional argument from Art. B 12 h ADR Rules are added: Although the appellant requests the revocation and transfer of the domain names at issue, in reality it aims to obtain the same domain names in order to be able to sell them immediately. The arbitration committee derives this conclusion both from the respondent’s well-founded reply and from the already extensive case law of the Czech Arbitral Tribunal to the detriment of the complainant. Incidentally, the Arbitral Commission allows itself to draw up the following set of experiences from the facts: Natural or legal persons who, after the publication of Regulation 874/2004, have applied for trademarks in mass on legal systems that are unrelated to their own business activities, hereby unduly have regard to the advantages of the art. 10 and 11 Regulation 874/2004. Because their behaviour circumvented the wording of the above regulations. This tactic can therefore undoubtedly be considered abusive. However, it would be inconsistent if we had opened the floodgates to the above-mentioned tactics via complaints.
Finally, the Arbitral Commission is aware that the current domain owner is a company that has chosen exactly the same business model as the complainant. Therefore, under no circumstances should the present judgment be considered to be a carte blanche for this conduct. The arguments of the complainant must be accepted in many places in substantive terms. What is missing in this case, however, is the legal protection need for the revocation and transfer of the domain names in dispute on the part of the complainant, which is why the complaint was rejected.
Decision
For all the above reasons and in accordance with Section B 12 (h) of the Rules, the Arbitral Commission hereby decrees that:
the complaint is rejected;
Members of the Arbitral Commission
Apostolos anthimos
Date: 2007-02-26
Appendix 1
The complainant is a Cypriot firm, which has registered approximately 140 trademarks in Malta. The respondent is an Austrian firm, which has registered more than 100 trademarks in Sweden, Belgium and Austria. Both parties have registered almost exclusively generic / descriptive terms in the German language. The complainant asks for the revocation of the disputed domain names and their transfer to him, because of his earlier registrations in Malta. Apart from the above, he underlines that the respondent’s trademark registrations are contrary to the meaning of Art. 11 PPR, since they contain ampersands that had to be transcribed at the domain name registration stage.
It was held that the mere registration of trade marks does not always confer prior rights to the owner, especially when it is apparent that they were registered for the purpose of obtaining the disputed domain name in the .eu sunrise period, without supplying any persuasive explanation or supporting evidence indicating a genuine intention to use the mark. The respondent produced a number of earlier CAC decisions, which served as serious evidence that the complainant has exercised this pattern excessively in the past, i.e. from the time starting with the publication of the PPR until the beginning of the Sunrise Period. This pattern of behaviour constitutes a fraudulent attempt to take advantage of the wording of Art. 10 PPR. Thus, any domain name registration emanating from such a background should be regarded as speculative and abusive.
The above conclusion remains the same regardless if one deals with the complainant or the respondent. In the case before hand, it was evidenced that the complainant followed exactly the pattern aforementioned. Bearing in mind that Regulation 874/2004 does not contain any rules regarding the complainant’s standing to sue, the Panel applied Art. B 12 h ADR-Rules, which allows the Panel to reject the complaint as constituting an abuse of the administrative proceeding, if it has been proved that it was initiated in bad faith.
Practical examples
A company relies on its company. We prove their protection under the relevant law.
The address only leads to a deceptive page later. We document the later use.
A non-European applicant requests transfer. First of all, the .eu entitlement is examined.
The owner refers to his own project of the same name. Dated business documents are evaluated.